Loading
Loading
The Fourth Amendment protects you from arrest without probable cause. When officers violate this right, you can sue for the wrongful deprivation of your liberty.
The Fourth Amendment protects against unreasonable seizures—including arrest without probable cause.
An arrest is a seizure of your person. Even brief detentions trigger Fourth Amendment protection.
Officers must have facts sufficient to warrant a reasonable person to believe a crime was committed.
Courts ask whether a reasonable officer would believe probable cause existed—not whether THIS officer believed it.
The officer's after-the-fact justifications don't count. Only facts known at the time of arrest matter.
Probable cause exists when facts and circumstances known to the officer would lead a reasonable person to believe a crime was committed. It's more than a hunch but less than proof beyond reasonable doubt.
Courts evaluate probable cause based on what the officer knew at the moment of arrest—not what was discovered later. Evidence found after arrest can't retroactively justify an arrest that lacked initial probable cause.
| Scenario | Description | Claim Strength |
|---|---|---|
| Mistaken Identity | Arrested because you matched a vague description or shared a name with someone else | Strong if description was generic |
| Fabricated Evidence | Officer lied about what they observed or manufactured evidence to justify arrest | Very strong |
| Wrong Address Warrant | Executed warrant at wrong location, arresting innocent residents | Strong |
| Retaliatory Arrest | Arrested for exercising First Amendment rights (filming police, protests) | Strong with evidence of motive |
| Pretext Arrests | Minor violation used as excuse to arrest someone the officer targeted | Moderate—requires proving lack of cause |
| Failure to Investigate | Officer ignored obvious exculpatory information before arresting | Strong if ignored info was significant |
Counter: Find prior cases with similar facts establishing the right to be free from this exact type of arrest
Counter: Attack each fact the officer relies on—were they reliable? Fabricated? Exaggerated?
Counter: Challenge whether the warrant application contained false statements or material omissions
Counter: Demand who told them what, when—break the chain if information was unreliable
Counter: Even if insufficient, officers may be immune if 'reasonable minds could differ'
| Category | Examples |
|---|---|
| Compensatory Damages | Lost wages, attorney's fees for criminal defense, medical expenses from jail conditions |
| Emotional Distress | Humiliation, anxiety, depression, PTSD, damage to mental health |
| Reputational Harm | Loss of employment, damage to relationships, community standing |
| Physical Harm | Injuries during arrest, inadequate medical care while detained |
| Punitive Damages | When officer's conduct was intentional, reckless, or showed conscious disregard for rights |
Any detention matters, but longer custody increases damages significantly
Jail conditions, cell assignments, treatment by staff all affect damages
Whether the arrest was witnessed, publicized, or affected employment
Time spent fighting charges before dismissal compounds harm
A wrongful arrest violates your constitutional rights. We fight to hold officers and departments accountable for unlawful seizures.